Sunday, March 3, 2013

Reading Response 3 - Doug Hinkel


            In its simplest and broadest definition, a meme is an idea.  On a deeper level, I would describe a meme as a form of communication – a transmission device that allows one individual’s thoughts and visions to enter the mind of another.   Memes are anything and everything that surrounds us.
            According to Dawkins, memes and genes are the only two things that can be passed from one human to the other.  Decreasing by 50 percent with each passing generation, Dawkins explains that genes deteriorate over time, but that memes are capable of persisting much longer; a good poem, song, or invention will stick around long after the meme’s originator has passed.  But, is it possible for memes to ever be eradicated?  Genes are a physical thing, so when their physical matter is no longer present, then they are gone.  However, memes are not tangible and can only live within the minds of living creatures.  So if the last living creature to possess the meme/idea within its mind were to die, would it be accurate to say that the meme no longer exists either?  Beautiful minds such as Albert Einstein and Galileo Galilei likely possessed memes that they never released into the world, so I would argue that they no longer exist, but what about the memes that are released into the world?  Even if the minds that held them no longer exist, does that mean the meme itself no longer exists?
            Sorry for the tangent.  Allow me to get back on track with the response questions.  A meme is an intellectual term coined by a brilliant man who attempted to explore the word by examining its meanings and implications.  Today, most people understand a meme to be a witty, often one-dimensional, idea that is presented via the Internet using pictures and words.  Starting as an idea (essentially about an idea), the meme has been marginalized to a specific medium and often assumes rather insignificant meaning. 
This is a prime example of why applying biological theories to culture is rarely successful.  People tend to dumb down ideas so that they are more easily accessible for the general public.  If one is to examine most cultural traditions, beliefs, and practices, it is not difficult to see that they often lack depth or rationale.  For this reason, we should be careful when we apply biological theories to culture.  One is equipped with carefully reasoned ideas, while the other is filled with norms that were created by someone trying to give purpose and meaning to their life, without taking the time to realize the absurdity of their claims.  Most biological theories will only lose their weight and depth if blended with culture.
If memes are a way of communicating ideas, then they are essential to “convergence media,” which is reliant on a collaboration of ideas between multiple individuals.  It has been evident through the presentations so far, that artwork is becoming a much more collective process where several people work together to convey an idea or meme.  Memes are a form of art, but we must be careful to not let the attractive and entertaining nature of such work take away from the deeper ideas embedded within the work.  We also cannot let the inherently pleasurable qualities of “convergence media” be an excuse to abandon the thought, meaning, and introspection that so often inspires great art pieces.
            I do not have a specific link to post, but I would suggest that people visit different meme websites and think about how easily accessible art is becoming.  Where it used to be that art – painting, sculpting, singing, dancing, etc. – took talent to be recognized and distributed to a mass audience (based on publicity for it being a quality art piece), that anybody can create art and have it seen by millions of people around the world.  While I do recognize the vast opportunities and advantages presented by such a connected, accessible culture, I do think that it takes away from importance and recognition some brilliant art pieces deserve.  

No comments:

Post a Comment